The Definition of Open Tendering
Open tendering is a competitive procurement process for acquiring products or services from external suppliers. It involves releasing a public notice inviting interested vendors to submit their proposals, which are then evaluated based on predetermined criteria. Acknowledging tenders is a fundamental requirement of an open tendering process to ensure fair competition and transparency.
This means that every supplier should have equal access to the tender information, and the evaluation criteria should be clearly defined and communicated to all tender participants. The tender process should be conducted fairly and impartially, without bias to any specific supplier.
The outcome of the tender should be based solely on the price, quality and suitability of the proposals submitted by each supplier, and the supplier with the best proposal should be awarded the tender. Open tendering is often the preferred competitive procedure for purchasing products or services, the fundamental requirements of which are that tenders should:
- Be open to all qualified and interested suppliers.
- Have objective qualification criteria.
- Specify neutral and precise technical specifications.
- Be advertised by a means that is open to all.
- Engender a clear and accurate evaluation criterion.
- Only be awarded to the most cost-advantageous bid.
Ensuring Open Competition
When conducting a tender process, it is essential to ensure it is transparent, fair, and open. To
achieve this, it is necessary to use an objective method for selecting the winning supplier that allows for the selection of the most commercially advantageous solution based on a price/quality criterion that is both easy to understand and to implement.
The price/quality criteria used in the selection process can be based on a ratio that utilises either price or quality as the determinant factor. It is important to note that the market is typically driven by price, which will play a significant role in buying decisions. However, in cases where quality is more important, creating a prequalified list of the essential attributes of the purchase may be necessary to formalise a baseline upon which the buying decision can be based. In such cases, price will be the minor determinant factor.
An open tender process is the most effective way to promote competition, introducing the most significant price competition and value for money. However, some argue that the open tendering process is overly complex due to its procedural nature and is designed primarily to procure simple purchases that are straightforward to describe. This may not be suitable for complex procurements, where the emphasis is on the output and outcome rather than adherence to standards.
The Suitability of Tendering
It is essential to carefully consider the tender process that will be used for each procurement, considering the specific requirements of the purchase. This will help to ensure that the process is fair, transparent, and open to all bidders and that the chosen supplier can provide the most commercially advantageous solution based on the price/quality criterion that has been established. The disadvantages of open tendering are:
- An extended timeframe for the completion of the process.
- It requires strict adherence to administrative procedures.
- The capacity for the creation of clear and precise specifications.
- Suppliers are restricted in determining the technical requirements.
- It limits the building of long-term Supplier relationships.
- It tends to focus only on the least-cost solution.
- Formalisation could limit supplier participation.
The Need for Open Tendering
Open Tendering is a procurement process that enables organisations to request products or services from the open market without showing any bias towards any supplier. The process starts with the organisation issuing a tender notice and formally inviting suppliers to submit bids for the required products or services. The notice contains all the necessary information, such as the scope of work, technical specifications, evaluation criteria, and the deadline for submission.
However, the challenging part of the tender process is creating a product or service specification. Many organisations struggle to draft an accurate and comprehensive specification that meets their needs and requirements. The specification is the foundation of the tender process, and any error or ambiguity can result in receiving bids that may not meet the organisation's needs.
One of the most significant benefits of open tendering is that it allows people to reach a consensus on the essential attributes of the product or service requirements specification. A cross-functional team, including representatives from the technical, financial, and legal departments, must be involved in creating the specification. This will ensure the specification is comprehensive, accurate, and reflects the organisation's needs.
Reaching that consensus takes time and patience, but it will be one of the most significant success factors in selecting a product or service that best meets the organisation's needs. Once the specification is finalised, it's included in the tender notice, and suppliers are invited to submit their bids. The organisation then evaluates the bids based on the evaluation criteria outlined in the notice. It selects the supplier who offers the best value for money and meets the organisation's needs.
The Advantages of Open Tendering
One of the primary benefits of using open tendering is that it offers an equal opportunity for all suppliers to participate in the procurement process. This encourages maximum participation from suppliers and ensures that the organisation receives competitive bids. The open and transparent nature of the process also reduces the risk of corruption or favouritism.
Moreover, open tendering leads to the highest price competition within the open market. Suppliers are encouraged to offer competitive prices, which can result in significant cost savings for the organisation. This competition incentivises suppliers to provide unique and innovative solutions, promoting competition and technological advancements that can improve product or service quality.
However, it must be emphasised that open tendering is often believed to be biased towards the least-cost option. This is not always the case and depends on the scoring criterion used to judge the suitability of suppliers' tender submissions. Where price is not the primary concern of a potential requirements solution, the tender's price/quality scoring ratio must be carefully considered to find a balance that best meets the organisation's needs.
Open tendering is a fair, transparent, and competitive procurement process that offers equal opportunity to all suppliers. It encourages innovation and leads to cost savings for the organisation and technological advancements for the industry. Organisations should consider the price/quality balance that best meets their needs to ensure an open tender process is fair and unbiased.
Simply opting for the lowest-cost option may not necessarily be the best award decision within a tender, as it may compromise the quality of the product or service an organisation receives. By weighing the award of a tender based on the price against quality to best meet the organisation's requirements, organisations can make an informed, cost-effective decision that meets their needs without the result of a tender being driven solely or predominantly by cost alone.
More articles can be found at Procurement and Supply Chain Management Made Simple. A look at procurement and supply chain management issues to assist organisations and people in increasing the quality, efficiency, and effectiveness in the supply of their products and services to customers' delight. ©️ Procurement and Supply Chain Management Made Simple. All rights reserved.
